Project Management migration

Migrate from Allfred to Trello

Field-level mapping, validation, and rollback between Allfred and Trello. We move data and schema; workflows are rebuilt natively in Trello.

Allfred logo

Allfred

Source

Trello

Destination

Trello logo

Compatibility

42%

5 of 12

objects map 1:1 between Allfred and Trello.

Complexity

BStandard

Timeline

3-5 weeks

Rollback included Accuracy guarantee Field-level validation

Overview

What this migration involves

Allfred and Trello occupy opposite ends of the PM complexity spectrum. Allfred is an agency operations platform with a multi-entity data model: Projects contain Tasks with Subtasks, and Clients, Brands, and Contractors exist as top-level objects with billing fields and unlimited file storage. Trello is a kanban-centric board tool that organizes work inside Workspaces and Boards, where Cards represent tasks and checklists represent subtasks. There is no native Client, Brand, or Contractor object in Trello, and custom field support is limited to Premium and Enterprise tiers. We resolve this structural mismatch during migration scoping: Projects map to Boards, Clients and Brands map to linked cards in a dedicated board or to card descriptions, Contractor rate fields map to Trello card assignees with a custom rate field, and Subtasks become checklists. We extract Allfred data via the manual Settings export and load it through Trello's REST API with rate-limit handling and chunked batch processing. Allfred automations, Trello Butler rules, and reporting configurations do not migrate; we deliver written inventories for admin rebuild.

Field-level fidelity

Every standard and custom field arrives verified.

Schema-aware mapping

AI proposes the map; you confirm before any record moves.

Relationships preserved

Parent–child, lookups, and ownership stay linked.

Full activity history

Calls, emails, meetings — with original timestamps.

Attachments & notes

Documents, uploads, and inline notes move with the record.

Why teams make this switch

Two sides of the same decision

Leaving

Allfred logo

Allfred

What's pushing teams away

  • Occasional loading delays during platform updates frustrate teams during active project work when seconds matter
  • Limited third-party integrations outside SharePoint forces agencies to rebuild workflows or abandon tools they already rely on
  • Smaller ecosystem and community compared to established PM platforms like Monday.com or Asana means fewer pre-built templates and workflow recipes
  • Onboarding takes days to weeks depending on team size, which can feel slow for smaller agencies wanting immediate access
  • G2 rating of 4.7 with only 53 reviews suggests a relatively small customer base, making peer references and case studies harder to find

Choosing

Trello logo

Trello

What's pulling them in

  • Free plan supports unlimited users and 10 boards, giving small teams full access to core Kanban functionality before any paid commitment is required.
  • The drag-and-drop board/card/Label interface requires no training, which reduces adoption friction and onboarding time across distributed teams.
  • Atlassian ecosystem integration with Jira, Confluence, and Bitbucket provides native cross-tool workflows for teams already using Atlassian tools.
  • Butler automation on paid tiers enables rule-based triggers without third-party integrations, covering basic workflow automation needs.
  • Simple visual task management with due dates, checklists, and member assignments keeps individual contributors and small teams organized without complexity.

Object mapping

How Allfred objects map to Trello

Each row shows how a Allfred object lands in Trello, including any object-level transformations, lookup resolution, or schema-design dependencies.

Typical mapping — final map is confirmed during the sample migration step.

Allfred

Project

maps to

Trello

Board

1:1
Fully supported

Allfred Projects map directly to Trello Boards within a Trello Workspace. We create one Workspace per Allfred data export or per agency client grouping, then create a Board per Allfred Project. Project name, description, status, start date, and due date migrate as Board metadata. Allfred project team assignments map to Trello Board members. The Workspace is created first so Board creation references a valid Workspace ID. This mapping is 1:1 and stable across all Allfred and Trello tiers.

Allfred

Task

maps to

Trello

Card

1:1
Fully supported

Allfred Tasks map to Trello Cards on the corresponding Board. Title, description, assignee, due date, priority, and status migrate as Card fields. Task hierarchy (parent task to subtask) is preserved by nesting subtasks under their parent as Trello checklist items. Status mapping uses Allfred task status values mapped to the target Board list names we configure during scoping. Open tasks land in the first list (e.g., To Do), in-progress tasks in the second (Doing), and completed tasks in the final list (Done).

Allfred

Subtask

maps to

Trello

Checklist item

1:1
Fully supported

Allfred Subtasks flatten into Trello Checklist items attached to the parent Card. Each Subtask title becomes a Checklist item; Subtask assignee and due date are appended to the checklist item text as a formatted note. Checklist item completion state migrates from Allfred subtask status. If Allfred subtasks have their own subtasks (nested depth), we flatten all levels into a single checklist hierarchy. Trello imposes a 200-item checklist limit per card; deeply nested Allfred subtask trees exceeding this threshold require splitting across multiple cards, flagged during scoping.

Allfred

Client

maps to

Trello

Board or Card (linked)

lossy
Fully supported

Allfred Client records have no native Trello equivalent. We discuss the preferred strategy during scoping: Option A creates a dedicated Trello Board per Client with project boards linked via card URLs; Option B stores Client name and contact details in a card description on a Client board with Cards representing individual engagements. Client-to-Brand relationships are preserved as card labels or linked Card descriptions. Allfred contact fields (phone, email, address) migrate to Trello Card descriptions in a structured format. This object does not exist natively in Trello; post-migration workflow changes are required.

Allfred

Brand

maps to

Trello

Board or Card (linked)

lossy
Fully supported

Allfred Brand records (brand name, logo URL, color palette, guidelines) have no native Trello equivalent. We apply the same strategy as Client mapping: either a dedicated Brand Board with linked project cards or brand fields stored in Card descriptions. Brand logo and color palette are stored as card attachments or in the card description as structured text. The Client-to-Brand parent relationship migrates as card labeling (Brand name as label) or as a cross-board Card URL link.

Allfred

Contractor

maps to

Trello

Board member + custom field

1:many
Fully supported

Allfred Contractor records contain name, contact details, hourly rate, and assignment history, with no direct Trello object. We add contractors as Trello Workspace members (or Board members if the contractor should not access all boards) and store their hourly rate in a Trello custom field on the cards they are assigned to. The assignment history (which projects and tasks a contractor worked on) is preserved as the contractor's Card assignee role across the relevant cards. Archived contractors migrate as inactive Workspace members. Trello does not support billing rate fields natively; we use a custom number field on cards to carry rate data, or document the rate in the card description.

Allfred

Team Member

maps to

Trello

Workspace member

1:1
Fully supported

Allfred Team Member records (name, email, role, avatar) map to Trello Workspace members. Role information is preserved in a Trello custom text field on Cards or in the card description. Team Member assignment history on tasks and projects migrates as Card assignee records. Active team members are invited to the Workspace before migration; archived or deactivated Allfred users are migrated as inactive Workspace members. Allfred role distinctions (Admin, Member, Contractor) must be manually re-established in Trello Workspace settings after migration.

Allfred

Kanban Board

maps to

Trello

Board lists

1:1
Fully supported

Allfred Kanban board column names and card-to-column assignments map to Trello Board list names and Card positions within those lists. Column order is preserved. Allfred column states (active, archived, color-coded) are stored as Trello list names and optional list colors. Column naming conventions vary by Allfred project; we extract all distinct column names during discovery and configure the target Board with matching list names before cards are placed. If a card in Allfred exists in multiple column states, the most recent state determines the destination list.

Allfred

Custom Field

maps to

Trello

Card custom field

lossy
Fully supported

Allfred per-project custom fields require explicit mapping against Trello's supported types: dropdown, date, number, text, checkbox, and rating. Any Allfred field type not in this list (currency, percentage, URL, etc.) is converted to the closest Trello type and flagged for customer review. Custom fields in Allfred exist per-project with no global schema; we extract all unique field definitions across all projects, deduplicate by name and type, and create Trello Board-level custom fields on the corresponding target Board. Trello custom fields require Premium ($10/user/month) or Enterprise; Standard tier does not support them. We confirm the destination tier during scoping and alert the customer if the target account's tier does not support custom fields.

Allfred

File Attachment

maps to

Trello

Card attachment

lossy
Fully supported

Allfred file attachments linked to Projects, Tasks, and Clients migrate as Trello Card attachments. Allfred's 2 GB per-file limit is larger than Trello's Standard tier limit of 250 MB per attachment; we identify files exceeding this threshold during discovery and present three options: chunking (for supported file types), storing as an external URL reference (SharePoint links preserved as-is), or excluding from migration with a manifest provided to the customer. Trello Enterprise raises the limit to 2 GB. File attachment links on Cards preserve the original file name and URL for reference.

Allfred

Settings and Preferences

maps to

Trello

Workspace settings

lossy
Mapping required

Allfred workspace configuration, notification preferences, and integration settings cannot migrate as a data record because Trello stores workspace settings separately from card data. We export Allfred settings as a JSON manifest during the discovery export and present it as a setup guide for the customer to manually reconfigure in Trello Workspace settings post-migration. This includes notification preferences, SharePoint integration settings, and any Allfred-specific workspace-level configurations that do not have a Trello equivalent.

Allfred

Pipeline

maps to

Trello

Board + list structure

lossy
Fully supported

Allfred deal pipelines and project pipelines map to Trello Board structures. Each Allfred pipeline becomes a separate Trello Board, and each stage within the pipeline becomes a Trello list in column order. Allfred pipeline-level custom fields map to Trello Board-level custom fields on the corresponding Board. If the customer uses Allfred for project and deal tracking simultaneously, we create separate Workspace sections for project Boards and deal Boards to maintain logical separation. Pipeline-level reporting requires Trello Power-Ups (such as Corrello or Screenful) post-migration.

Gotchas + challenges

What specifically takes care here

Platform-specific issues from each side, plus the pair-specific challenges that don't show up on either platform's page on its own.

Allfred logo

Allfred gotchas

High

No publicly documented API for bulk data export

Medium

Custom fields have no fixed global schema

Medium

SharePoint integration files export as URL references only

Low

Loading delays during platform updates cause brief outages

Trello logo

Trello gotchas

High

Billing model uses maximum seat quantity at term midpoint

Medium

Custom Field data historically stored in pluginData

Medium

API rate limits are token-gated and can block bulk migration

Medium

Guest-to-paid seat conversion triggers on multi-board membership

Low

Automation command runs are capped per plan and overage triggers upgrade pressure

Pair-specific challenges

  • Trello attachment size limits can block file migration

    Trello Standard caps file attachments at 250 MB per file, while Allfred allows up to 2 GB per file. Files exceeding 250 MB will fail during attachment migration. We identify all oversized files during discovery, chunk compatible file types (such as text-based assets), and flag the remainder as URL-only migrations or exclusions with a manifest. Trello Enterprise raises the limit to 2 GB; if the customer plans to use Enterprise, we confirm this before migration and adjust the file strategy accordingly.

  • Archived cards do not appear in Trello exports

    Trello's native export and API exclude archived cards by default. If Allfred projects contain archived tasks that should migrate, those records are not captured unless they are unarchived in Allfred before the export runs. We request that customers unarchive any relevant Allfred tasks prior to migration scoping, or we run a separate manual pass to identify and flag archived records for manual restoration. This is a Trello platform limitation documented in Atlassian community threads, not an Allfred-specific issue.

  • Custom fields require a paid Trello tier

    Trello custom fields (dropdown, date, number, text, checkbox, rating) are only available on Premium ($10/user/month) and Enterprise ($17.50/user/month) tiers. The Standard free plan and the free tier do not support custom fields. If the migration destination is a Standard-tier Trello account, all Allfred custom field values are flagged for migration as Trello Card descriptions in structured text format. We confirm the destination tier during scoping and alert customers whose data model relies heavily on custom fields before migration begins.

  • Trello has no native Client or Brand object

    Allfred's Client and Brand objects have no direct Trello equivalent. The mapping strategy (dedicated board per client, card-linked external records, or card description fields) must be chosen during scoping. Each strategy affects how Allfred Client-to-Brand and Client-to-Project relationships are represented in Trello. If the agency manages multiple external clients with strict data separation, the dedicated board per client approach is recommended. We document the chosen strategy and its implications for post-migration workflows in the migration scope agreement before data movement begins.

  • Butler rules and Allfred workflows do not migrate

    Allfred workflow rules and Trello Butler automations are both platform-native automation layers that do not export or import as code. We do not migrate them. We deliver a written inventory of every active Allfred workflow (trigger, conditions, actions) and a written map of equivalent Butler rules for the customer to rebuild in Trello. This includes Allfred notification rules, status-change triggers, and contractor assignment automations. The inventory is delivered during the discovery phase and is included in the migration package.

Migration approach

Six steps for a successful Allfred to Trello data migration

  1. Discovery and export preparation

    We request a fresh Allfred data export from Settings > Account > Data Export immediately before migration scoping to minimize stale data. We audit the export for Projects, Tasks, Subtasks, Clients, Brands, Contractors, Team Members, Kanban board column names, custom field definitions, file attachment inventory, and any archived records. We review Allfred workspace settings and notification preferences to build the post-migration Trello setup guide. We confirm the destination Trello account tier (Free, Standard, Premium, or Enterprise) and verify custom field and attachment limits before proceeding.

  2. Workspace and Board schema design

    We design the Trello Workspace structure based on the Allfred project hierarchy. Each Allfred Project becomes a Trello Board inside a Workspace (one Workspace per agency or per major client grouping). We configure Board lists using Allfred Kanban column names, map Allfred task statuses to list positions, and pre-create any required Trello custom fields (Premium and above) to match Allfred custom field definitions. If Client and Brand objects require a dedicated Board strategy, we create that Board first and configure cross-board linking before project Boards are built.

  3. Contractor and team member provisioning

    We extract all Allfred Contractor and Team Member records and provision them as Trello Workspace members before any card migration begins. Contractors receive Workspace or Board membership based on the chosen access strategy, with their hourly rate stored in a pre-created custom number field. Team members are invited to the Workspace and assigned their Allfred role as a custom text field on cards. Any Allfred Contractor or Team Member without a valid email address goes to a reconciliation queue for the customer to resolve before migration resumes.

  4. Project and Task migration in dependency order

    We migrate Projects (as Trello Boards) first, then Tasks (as Cards) within each Board, with Subtasks attached as Checklist items on the parent Card. Allfred task hierarchy is resolved by matching each task's parent_id to the migrated Card ID before the checklist item is created. Allfred task status maps to the target Board list name; column naming from Allfred Kanban boards is applied during Board creation so Card placement lands in the correct list. Client and Brand associations migrate as Card labels, card descriptions, or cross-board links depending on the chosen strategy.

  5. File attachment migration and size handling

    We process Allfred file attachments in parallel with card migration, uploading each to the corresponding Trello Card. Files under 250 MB upload directly; files between 250 MB and 2 GB are handled per the customer's chosen strategy (URL reference, chunking, or exclusion). We generate a file manifest listing every migrated attachment, every oversized file with its chosen handling method, and every excluded file with its reason. SharePoint integration links from Allfred are preserved as-is as card URL attachments and flagged for the customer to verify access post-migration.

  6. Cutover, validation, and automation handoff

    We freeze Allfred writes during cutover, run a delta migration for any records modified during the migration window, and validate the Trello destination against the Allfred source for record counts, checklist completeness, and attachment presence. We deliver the Allfred workflow inventory and Butler rebuild guide to the customer's admin team. We support a one-week post-migration window for reconciliation issues raised by the team. We do not rebuild Allfred workflows as Butler rules or configure Trello Power-Ups as part of the standard migration scope; those are separate configuration tasks.

Platform deep dives

Context on both ends of the pair

Allfred logo

Allfred

Source

Strengths

  • Unlimited file storage removes storage anxiety for creative and media-heavy agency teams
  • SharePoint integration lets Microsoft 365 shops keep files in their existing ecosystem
  • Step-by-step onboarding with hands-on data import reduces setup friction for new teams
  • 24/7 support ensures distributed teams across time zones get timely assistance
  • 4.7 rating on G2 from 53 reviews indicates generally satisfied customers despite loading delay complaints

Weaknesses

  • Only 53 G2 reviews suggests a relatively small and unproven customer base compared to established PM platforms
  • Limited third-party integrations beyond SharePoint requires workarounds or abandoned tools for complex tech stacks
  • Occasional loading delays during updates disrupt active work sessions
  • No publicly documented API for programmatic data access limits automation possibilities
  • Onboarding takes days to weeks depending on team size, slower than self-serve alternatives
Trello logo

Trello

Destination

Strengths

  • Generous free tier with unlimited users and 10 boards, the lowest barrier to entry among major project management tools.
  • Intuitive drag-and-drop Kanban interface requires no training or onboarding documentation.
  • Deep Atlassian integration with Jira, Confluence, and Bitbucket for teams already in the ecosystem.
  • Built-in Butler automation covers rule-based triggers without requiring third-party integrations.
  • REST API with comprehensive documentation enables programmatic access to all core objects.

Weaknesses

  • Reporting and analytics are absent, with no built-in velocity tracking, burndown charts, or historical performance metrics.
  • The flat board/list/card data model scales poorly for complex projects requiring hierarchical task structures.
  • Customization is limited compared to platforms like Asana, monday.com, or Jira that offer richer field types and workflow configuration.
  • Advanced views (Timeline, Dashboard) require Premium and are not available on Standard, inflating total cost for teams needing visibility features.
  • Guest user billing rules are confusing and prone to accidental seat overages when guests join multiple boards.

Complexity grading

How hard is this migration?

Standard Project Management migration. 2 of 8 objects need a mapping; the rest are 1:1.

B

Overall complexity

Standard migration

Derived from compatibility, mapping clarity, API constraints, and data volume across Allfred and Trello.

  • Object compatibility

    B

    2 of 8 objects need a mapping; the rest are 1:1.

  • Field mapping clarity

    C

    Field mapping is derived from defaults — final spec confirmed during the sample migration.

  • Timeline complexity

    B

    8-object category — typical timelines run 2–7 days end-to-end.

  • API constraints

    B

    Allfred: Not publicly documented.

  • Data volume sensitivity

    B

    Allfred doesn't expose a bulk API — REST + parallelization used for high-volume runs.

Estimator

Estimate your Allfred to Trello migration cost

Rule-based pricing — no per-record fees, no manual quotes. Migrations over 2M records are scoped individually.

Step 1

What are you migrating?

Pick a category, then your source and destination platforms.

Category

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about Allfred to Trello data migrations

Answers to the questions buyers ask most during Allfred to Trello migration scoping. Not seeing yours? Book a call.

Can't find your answer?

Walk through your Allfred to Trello migration with a real engineer — 30 minutes, free, written quote within 24 hours.

Book a free 30 minute consultation

Most Allfred to Trello migrations complete in three to five weeks. Three to four weeks covers migrations of up to 20 Allfred Projects with no complex custom field schemas and no large file attachments. Six to eight weeks applies when the migration involves multiple Trello Workspaces, Allfred custom fields requiring type conversion, file attachments near the 250 MB limit, or a dedicated Board-per-Client strategy that requires structural scoping before data movement begins. We provide a detailed timeline estimate after discovery, once board count and attachment inventory are confirmed.

Adjacent paths

Related migrations to explore

Ready when you are

Move from Allfred.
Land in Trello, intact.

Tell us record counts and timeline. We'll come back with a written quote inside 1 business day — no commitment, no sales pitch.

Accuracy guarantee Rollback included Quote in 1 business day