HRMS migration

Migrate from Paycom to Crelate

Field-level mapping, validation, and rollback between Paycom and Crelate. We move data and schema; workflows are rebuilt natively in Crelate.

Paycom logo

Paycom

Source

Crelate

Destination

Crelate logo

Compatibility

75%

9 of 12

objects map 1:1 between Paycom and Crelate.

Complexity

BStandard

Timeline

4-6 weeks

Rollback included Accuracy guarantee Field-level validation

Overview

What this migration involves

Paycom and Crelate serve different stages of the talent lifecycle, which makes this migration a structural extraction rather than a like-for-like replacement. Paycom is a full HCM suite where employee records are the primary object, spanning payroll runs, PTO accruals, garnishment orders, timekeeping, and benefits enrollments all in one database. Crelate is a recruiting-focused ATS and CRM built around Contacts, Companies, Opportunities, and candidate Activities. We extract the recruiting-relevant subset from Paycom—employee records functioning as candidates, organizational units, and any pre-hire data—transform them into Crelate's Contact and Company model, and load them through Crelate's API with parent-lookup resolution. PTO accrual balances and garnishment computation rules do not migrate because Crelate has no payroll engine. We deliver a written inventory of Paycom automations and workflows requiring rebuild in Crelate for the customer's admin team.

Field-level fidelity

Every standard and custom field arrives verified.

Schema-aware mapping

AI proposes the map; you confirm before any record moves.

Relationships preserved

Parent–child, lookups, and ownership stay linked.

Full activity history

Calls, emails, meetings — with original timestamps.

Attachments & notes

Documents, uploads, and inline notes move with the record.

Why teams make this switch

Two sides of the same decision

Leaving

Paycom logo

Paycom

What's pushing teams away

  • Customer support is described as inconsistent—users report long wait times, unresponsive reps and incorrect troubleshooting guidance that left payroll errors unresolved for days.
  • Complexity grows with feature adoption; users report difficulty navigating between modules, finding specific settings and adapting workflows when the company scales or restructures.
  • Payroll delivery failures (late checks, unscheduled carrier changes to USPS without notice) caused direct financial harm for at least one mid-market customer who had to cut manual checks.
  • PTO accrual logic and garnishments are frequently cited as painful to configure and maintain, with errors persisting through multiple support escalations.
  • System rigidity and limited customization force some companies to maintain parallel spreadsheets or shadow systems for workflows Paycom cannot accommodate.

Choosing

Crelate logo

Crelate

What's pulling them in

  • Affordable per-seat pricing with transparent tiers makes Crelate accessible for small-to-mid staffing firms evaluating ATS platforms for the first time.
  • Fast implementation reported by customers—some describe getting live in a matter of minutes with support team assistance.
  • Unified ATS + CRM in a single product eliminates the need to buy and synchronize separate recruiting and sales tools.
  • Flexible custom fields across Contacts, Companies, and Opportunities allow recruiting teams to capture firm-specific data without developer involvement.
  • Positive reviews highlight the product's intuitive interface and functional breadth for teams that need recruiting workflows without enterprise overhead.

Object mapping

How Paycom objects map to Crelate

Each row shows how a Paycom object lands in Crelate, including any object-level transformations, lookup resolution, or schema-design dependencies.

Typical mapping — final map is confirmed during the sample migration step.

Paycom

Employee

maps to

Crelate

Contact

1:1
Fully supported

Paycom Employee records function as candidate records when the migration scope is recruiting-focused. The four-character eecode is extracted as a legacy_id__c field in Crelate for dedupe and reconciliation. Employee first name, last name, email, phone, address, hire date, department, job title, employment status, and manager relationship all map directly to Crelate Contact fields. We flag employees with a candidate_flag custom field if they are to be surfaced in recruiting workflows, because not all Paycom employees are active recruiting prospects.

Paycom

Employee (organizational unit)

maps to

Crelate

Company

1:many
Fully supported

Paycom does not have a separate Company object; organizational hierarchy lives as department and division data within the Employee record. We extract distinct employer entities from the employee's company_name field (if populated) and from division or subsidiary designations, and create Crelate Company records. Each Company gets a unique company_id for subsequent Contact linking. Multiple employees from the same organization attach to one Company via the Contact-Company lookup.

Paycom

Custom New Hire Fields

maps to

Crelate

Contact Custom Fields

lossy
Mapping required

Paycom's get_new_hire_custom_fields endpoint exposes client-specific text, select, and date fields on the new hire profile. These map to Crelate custom fields on Contact that we pre-create during the schema design phase. Each Paycom custom field description becomes the Crelate field label, with the logical name assigned as the API field name. Picklist-type Paycom custom fields become Crelate picklist or multi-select fields with the same option values.

Paycom

Enhanced Background Check

maps to

Crelate

Contact Custom Field + Activity

1:1
Fully supported

Paycom background check results (status code, completion timestamp, flags) are extracted per candidate and stored as a Crelate Contact custom field for structured visibility and a Crelate Activity note for audit trail. Detailed criminal, credit, or drug screening results that cannot be stored in structured fields are documented as an Activity note with the check type and status.

Paycom

Vault Payroll Card enrollment

maps to

Crelate

Contact Custom Field

1:1
Fully supported

Paycom Vault payroll card enrollment status (boolean flag) and card delivery method are extracted from the employee record as a Crelate Contact custom field. This is a compliance-relevant flag for candidates who receive pay via payroll card; it migrates as a structured field rather than a note so that Crelate users can filter and report on it without opening a notes record.

Paycom

Employee Status History

maps to

Crelate

Contact Employment Status + Activity

1:many
Fully supported

Paycom Employee records carry hire date, termination date, rehire date, and status change events. The current employment status (active, terminated, leave of absence) maps to a Crelate Contact custom field; historical status transitions are captured as Crelate Activity records with type = Status Change and a note carrying the effective date and previous/new status. This preserves the status audit trail without creating duplicate Contact records.

Paycom

Timekeeping / Timecard Summary

maps to

Crelate

Contact Custom Field + Activity

1:1
Fully supported

Paycom timecard data (clock-in/out, total hours, overtime flags, absence punches) is employee-owned and manager-approved. We extract a summary snapshot as a Crelate Contact custom field (last submitted hours, overtime flag) and a general Activity note with the last completed pay period summary. Full timecard history does not map to Crelate because Crelate has no timekeeping engine; detailed punch data is documented as a migration inventory item for the customer's HR admin if a timekeeping platform is selected separately.

Paycom

Benefits Enrollment (pre-hire)

maps to

Crelate

Contact Custom Field + Activity

1:1
Fully supported

Pre-hire benefits elections (medical, dental, vision, 401k, HSA) stored in Paycom as enrollment records tied to candidates are extracted as Crelate Contact custom fields for plan type and coverage tier, plus an Activity note with plan name, deduction amount, and effective date. Post-hire benefits data (active employee enrollments) does not migrate because Crelate has no benefits administration module; we document it as an HR inventory item.

Paycom

Labor Allocation Distributions

maps to

Crelate

Company or Contact Custom Field

1:1
Fully supported

Paycom labor allocation distributions (department codes, job codes, GL codes, cost center splits) are stored per employee and tied to payroll costing. We extract the primary cost center and GL code as Crelate Company custom fields if the Company represents a department or cost center, or as Contact custom fields if the allocation is employee-specific. Multi-distribution splits (common in nonprofit grant-funded organizations with 20+ cost center allocations) are documented in a separate labor allocation inventory sheet.

Paycom

Payroll Run History

maps to

Crelate

Not Migrated

1:1
Fully supported

Historical payroll runs (gross pay, net pay, tax withholdings, deduction amounts) do not migrate to Crelate because Crelate has no payroll engine. We extract a payroll summary record per employee (most recent pay period gross, net, and federal tax withholding YTD) as a Crelate Contact custom field to support compensation-based recruiting tasks. Full payroll history is archived and delivered as a CSV export for the customer's payroll administrator or retained for audit purposes.

Paycom

PTO Accrual Balances

maps to

Crelate

Not Migrated

1:1
Fully supported

PTO accrual balances are computed by Paycom's rules engine and exposed as a current balance on the employee record. Crelate has no accrual engine, so the balance snapshot does not migrate as a functional field. We extract the as-of-date balance as a Crelate Contact custom field labeled pto_balance_snapshot__c with the effective date for reference. The customer's new PTO platform (if replacing Paycom entirely) re-computes accruals from hire date or accepts the snapshot as a starting balance.

Paycom

Garnishment Orders

maps to

Crelate

Not Migrated

1:1
Fully supported

Garnishment orders (child support, tax levies, wage assignments) carry deduction percentages computed internally by Paycom against federal and state guidelines. Crelate has no payroll engine and cannot apply garnishments. We extract the order record (begin date, amount, percentage vs. flat flag, exemption amounts, end date) as a Crelate Activity note on the Contact for the customer's HR admin to configure in the new payroll platform. The deduction computation does not migrate because it cannot be re-computed externally.

Gotchas + challenges

What specifically takes care here

Platform-specific issues from each side, plus the pair-specific challenges that don't show up on either platform's page on its own.

Paycom logo

Paycom gotchas

High

No self-serve bulk data export tool

Medium

Multi-data-center API routing required

Medium

PTO accrual logic cannot be re-computed externally

Medium

Garnishment calculation rules are opaque

Crelate logo

Crelate gotchas

High

120 req/min API rate limit throttles bulk migrations

High

20 custom field per-entity cap forces data model decisions

Medium

15,000-record export ceiling on single operations

Medium

Sequences and automation workflows do not migrate

Low

API key is a querystring parameter, not a header

Pair-specific challenges

  • Paycom has no self-serve bulk export; API access required

    Paycom does not provide a self-service download function for bulk data extraction. All migration extraction uses the Paycom REST API accessed via a client-specific SID and token. If API access has been restricted or revoked during contract termination, we coordinate a direct file request through Paycom's data team, which can add three to five business days to the timeline. During scoping, we require customers to confirm API credentials are active and retrieve the correct base URL for their data center (DFW, OKC, PHX, or Public) before extraction begins.

  • Employee-to-candidate schema split requires business logic

    Paycom's single-database model stores all persons as Employees; there is no separate candidate object. We extract Employee records as Crelate Contacts, but not all Employees are recruiting candidates. We apply a candidate_flag logic during scoping: employees with a candidate status in Paycom (identified via employee status, new hire custom fields, or background check records) are flagged as candidates, while active or terminated employees without a recruiting context are marked as non-candidates and delivered as archived Contacts. This split requires a business decision from the customer's recruiting and HR leadership before migration design begins.

  • Multi-data-center API routing must be confirmed before extraction

    Paycom operates four separate data center environments (DFW, OKC, PHX, and Public), and each customer's API base URL is determined by their account region. The Celigo integrator.io documentation lists base URLs for each: api.paycomdfw.net, api.paycomonline.net, api.phx.us-west.paycomonline.net, and www.paycomonline.net. We confirm the customer's data center during scoping and configure the correct base URL before beginning any API extraction. A wrong base URL produces 404 or authentication failures that are not immediately identifiable as routing issues, which can delay extraction by hours if not caught during test pings.

  • PTO accrual and garnishment rules cannot be re-computed in Crelate

    PTO accrual rules (accrual-per-pay-period, front-load, accrual-per-hour, carryover caps) are evaluated inside Paycom's rules engine and cannot be extracted or re-computed externally. Garnishment orders similarly carry maximum allowable deduction percentages computed internally against federal and state guidelines. We extract balance snapshots and order records as reference fields and Activity notes, but Crelate has no accrual engine and no payroll deduction engine. The customer must configure a new payroll platform (or retain a payroll provider) to re-enact accruals and garnishment deductions; we document the required configuration data in a structured payroll handoff sheet.

  • Custom new hire fields require Crelate pre-provisioning before load

    Paycom custom new hire fields are client-specific and exposed via the get_new_hire_custom_fields endpoint. Crelate requires custom fields to be created in Settings before data is loaded, and field types must match (text to short/long answer, picklist to picklist, date to date). We provision Crelate custom fields during the schema design phase based on the extracted Paycom field definitions. If a Paycom custom field has an unexpected value format or a picklist with more than 200 options, we flag it during scoping for the customer's admin to approve a truncation or consolidation strategy before Crelate provisioning begins.

Migration approach

Six steps for a successful Paycom to Crelate data migration

  1. Scoping and API access confirmation

    We audit the Paycom tenant for the full list of Employee records, custom new hire field definitions (via get_new_hire_custom_fields), background check records, benefits enrollment records, labor allocation distributions, and any Vault payroll card enrollment data. We confirm API credentials, retrieve the customer's data center base URL, and run a test ping to validate connectivity. We simultaneously review the Crelate destination tenant: existing Contact and Company field schemas, any pre-existing custom fields, and Opportunity record type configuration. The scoping output is a written migration scope document with a field-level mapping table and a custom field provisioning list for Crelate.

  2. Candidate flag logic and Employee-to-Contact split design

    We define the business logic for converting Paycom Employees to Crelate Contacts. The candidate_flag logic (which Employees are recruiting candidates versus HR records) is documented and approved by the customer's recruiting and HR leadership before migration design begins. We also design the Company split: distinct employer entities are extracted from Employee records and provisioned as Crelate Company records before any Contact import so that the Contact-Company lookup is satisfied at load time. If Paycom stores subsidiary or division data as separate entities, we create one Company per distinct organizational unit.

  3. Crelate custom field provisioning and schema deployment

    We pre-create all required Crelate custom fields based on the Paycom custom new hire field definitions extracted during scoping. Text fields become Crelate short or long answer fields; picklist fields become Crelate picklists with the same option values; date fields become Crelate date fields. We also provision custom fields for background check status, Vault enrollment, employment status, PTO balance snapshot, last payroll summary, and cost center/GL code. Custom fields are deployed into the Crelate test environment first for validation before production provisioning.

  4. Test migration and reconciliation

    We run a full migration into the Crelate test environment using a representative data volume. The customer's recruiting operations lead reconciles record counts (Contacts in, Companies in, Activities in), spot-checks 25-50 random Contacts against the Paycom source (name, email, eecode, hire date, department, custom field values), and reviews the Company-Contact linkage for accuracy. We also validate that picklist values map correctly, date fields display in the correct format, and Activity records attach to the correct Contact. Any mapping corrections and custom field type adjustments happen in the test environment before production migration begins.

  5. Production migration in dependency order

    We run production migration in record-dependency order: Companies first (from Paycom organizational entities), then Contacts (from Paycom Employees with candidate_flag applied), then Activities (background check records, benefits enrollment records, labor allocation notes as Activity notes). Custom fields are populated during the Contact and Company insert via Crelate's API. Each phase emits a row-count reconciliation report before the next phase begins. We freeze Paycom write access during the final cutover delta to capture any last-minute changes.

  6. Cutover, validation, and payroll data handoff

    We enable Crelate as the system of record for recruiting operations on the agreed cutover date, run a final delta migration of any records modified during the cutover window, and deliver the payroll data handoff sheet. The handoff sheet includes the PTO balance snapshot (with effective date), garnishment order records (with deduction parameters), and benefits enrollment records as structured CSV exports for the customer's new payroll platform administrator. We do not configure the new payroll platform or re-enact accrual and garnishment logic in Crelate; those are separate platform implementations. We deliver a written inventory of any Paycom recruiting workflows or automations requiring rebuild in Crelate's workflow builder.

Platform deep dives

Context on both ends of the pair

Paycom logo

Paycom

Source

Strengths

  • Single-database architecture means HR and payroll are always in sync with no cross-system reconciliation required.
  • Employee self-service model (timecard ownership, benefits enrollment, personal data updates) reduces HR admin workload at scale.
  • Beti automated payroll finds errors before submission, reportedly reducing payroll processing time by 90% in commissioned studies.
  • Native payroll processing for US, Canada, Ireland, Mexico and UK on one platform simplifies multi-country setups.
  • Built entirely in-house since 1998 rather than assembled via acquisition, which results in a more coherent product UX than competitors.

Weaknesses

  • PEPM pricing ($25–36) with implementation fees of 15–35% makes total cost of ownership high and creates a significant switching penalty.
  • Customer support is frequently described as inconsistent—long wait times, knowledgeable reps difficult to reach, incorrect guidance on complex issues.
  • System complexity grows quickly as companies add modules, making navigation between timekeeping, payroll and HR settings time-consuming for administrators.
  • PTO accrual configuration and garnishment setup are known friction points; errors persist through support escalations and require deep configuration re-work.
  • Limited public API documentation and no self-serve data export mean customers depend on Paycom for any bulk data extraction, including migrations.
Crelate logo

Crelate

Destination

Strengths

  • Unified ATS and CRM in a single platform reduces data synchronization overhead for recruiting teams.
  • Fast setup with guided implementation reported as a significant time saver for small teams.
  • Transparent per-seat pricing without surprise fees at the base tier.
  • Flexible custom field configuration across core objects without developer dependency.
  • Export capability supports up to 15,000 records per operation for Contacts, Companies, and Opportunities.

Weaknesses

  • API rate limit of 120 requests per minute restricts bulk migration throughput.
  • Custom field cap of 20 per entity requires field consolidation for complex recruiting schemas.
  • All advanced features (Activities, Activity Forms, Core Record Field customization) are tier-gated add-ons.
  • Customer service responsiveness receives consistent negative feedback in reviews.
  • Resume parsing quality trails competitors and generates support requests.

Complexity grading

How hard is this migration?

Standard HRMS migration. 1 of 7 objects need a mapping; the rest are 1:1.

B

Overall complexity

Standard migration

Derived from compatibility, mapping clarity, API constraints, and data volume across Paycom and Crelate.

  • Object compatibility

    B

    1 of 7 objects need a mapping; the rest are 1:1.

  • Field mapping clarity

    C

    Field mapping is derived from defaults — final spec confirmed during the sample migration.

  • Timeline complexity

    B

    7-object category — typical timelines run 2–7 days end-to-end.

  • API constraints

    B

    Paycom: Not publicly documented by Paycom.

  • Data volume sensitivity

    B

    Paycom doesn't expose a bulk API — REST + parallelization used for high-volume runs.

Estimator

Estimate your Paycom to Crelate migration cost

Rule-based pricing — no per-record fees, no manual quotes. Migrations over 2M records are scoped individually.

Step 1

What are you migrating?

Pick a category, then your source and destination platforms.

Category

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about Paycom to Crelate data migrations

Answers to the questions buyers ask most during Paycom to Crelate migration scoping. Not seeing yours? Book a call.

Can't find your answer?

Walk through your Paycom to Crelate migration with a real engineer — 30 minutes, free, written quote within 24 hours.

Book a free 30 minute consultation

Straightforward migrations of recruiting-relevant employee records (under 3,000 Contacts, no custom new hire fields, clean organizational split) complete in four to six weeks. Migrations with extensive custom new hire fields, complex labor allocation distributions, background check history, or concurrent Crelate sandbox validation move to ten to fourteen weeks because of Crelate custom field provisioning, multi-distribution labor allocation documentation, and the candidate flag reconciliation step.

Adjacent paths

Related migrations to explore

Ready when you are

Move from Paycom.
Land in Crelate, intact.

Tell us record counts and timeline. We'll come back with a written quote inside 1 business day — no commitment, no sales pitch.

Accuracy guarantee Rollback included Quote in 1 business day