HRMS migration

Migrate from Smart Hire to BambooHR

Field-level mapping, validation, and rollback between Smart Hire and BambooHR. We move data and schema; workflows are rebuilt natively in BambooHR.

Smart Hire logo

Smart Hire

Source

BambooHR

Destination

BambooHR logo

Compatibility

70%

7 of 10

objects map 1:1 between Smart Hire and BambooHR.

Complexity

BStandard

Timeline

3-5 weeks

Rollback included Accuracy guarantee Field-level validation

Overview

What this migration involves

Moving from Smart Hire to BambooHR is a migration from a CSV-first ATS focused on AI screening and psychometrics to a unified HRIS with native ATS, payroll, and performance management. Smart Hire exports are primarily CSV downloads rather than a documented REST API, which requires us to automate the download-and-parse workflow, validate field completeness during profiling, and normalize assessment scores before loading into BambooHR's custom fields. We preserve associations between candidates and job openings throughout the migration by reconstructing foreign key links across Smart Hire's separate export files. BambooHR's applicant tracking system is available on Pro and above plans ($17/employee/month) as a native module rather than a separate ATS purchase, which affects how job application data lands in the destination schema. Custom fields in BambooHR must be provisioned in the admin panel before migration, so we scope that step before any data loads. Workflows, email templates, and career site configurations from Smart Hire do not migrate; we deliver a written inventory of these for the customer's admin to rebuild in BambooHR.

Field-level fidelity

Every standard and custom field arrives verified.

Schema-aware mapping

AI proposes the map; you confirm before any record moves.

Relationships preserved

Parent–child, lookups, and ownership stay linked.

Full activity history

Calls, emails, meetings — with original timestamps.

Attachments & notes

Documents, uploads, and inline notes move with the record.

Why teams make this switch

Two sides of the same decision

Leaving

Smart Hire logo

Smart Hire

What's pushing teams away

  • Catalog website (smarthire-rh.com) currently returns connection errors — vendor presence and product continuity may be in doubt for this specific URL.
  • Multiple unrelated products share the 'Smart Hire' brand (smart-hire.ai, smarthire.website, usasmarthire.com, smart-hire.cloud, smarthire.app), creating confusion about which vendor is actually in scope.
  • No public API documentation surfaced through major review aggregators, limiting programmatic data extraction for migrations.
  • Pricing is not published for the catalog URL — buyers cannot evaluate cost without a sales conversation, and that conversation may not be possible if the site is non-responsive.
  • Very thin public review footprint for the specific smarthire-rh.com instance makes due diligence and vendor stability assessment difficult.

Choosing

BambooHR logo

BambooHR

What's pulling them in

  • Lowest friction entry point for SMBs moving off spreadsheets — intuitive interface means most teams are functional within days, not weeks.
  • Consolidation value: BambooHR merges ATS, onboarding, HR records, time-off, and payroll into a single pane of glass that employees never need to leave.
  • Volume discounts applied automatically by headcount, so pricing scales predictably as the company grows without renewal negotiations.
  • BambooHR reports most customers go live in four to six weeks, making it a realistic commitment for under-resourced HR teams.
  • Award-winning Support Heroes cited frequently in reviews — responsive human support after implementation is a differentiator.

Object mapping

How Smart Hire objects map to BambooHR

Each row shows how a Smart Hire object lands in BambooHR, including any object-level transformations, lookup resolution, or schema-design dependencies.

Typical mapping — final map is confirmed during the sample migration step.

Smart Hire

Candidate

maps to

BambooHR

Employee

1:1
Fully supported

Smart Hire candidate records map to BambooHR Employee. Contact details (name, email, phone, address), work history, education, and application status transfer as standard BambooHR employee fields. Smart Hire's main profile and any linked screening session data are combined into a single employee record, with screening notes stored in BambooHR's Notes tab or a custom Employee custom field.

Smart Hire

Candidate

maps to

BambooHR

Applicant (via Jobs module)

1:1
Fully supported

Smart Hire candidate application records map to BambooHR Applicants linked to BambooHR Job records. The candidate's application status (Applied, Screening, Interview, Offer, Hired) maps to the BambooHR applicant status vocabulary. If BambooHR's ATS module is not enabled on the destination account, candidates migrate as Employee records only and job association is stored via a custom field.

Smart Hire

Job Opening

maps to

BambooHR

Job

1:1
Fully supported

Smart Hire job openings (title, department, location, description) map directly to BambooHR Jobs. We preserve the job's open/closed status and map any Smart Hire pipeline stage configuration to the BambooHR job's internal stage list. Job posting URL and job board distribution references migrate as text fields on the Job record.

Smart Hire

Screening Session

maps to

BambooHR

Note or Custom Field

1:many
Fully supported

Smart Hire screening sessions are stored as linked records connecting a candidate to a specific assessment round. We export all session metadata (session date, type, round number, outcome) and re-attach it to the corresponding candidate's employee record in BambooHR. If multiple screening sessions exist for a single candidate, we aggregate them into a session history note or a custom multi-value field, depending on the volume.

Smart Hire

Psychometric Assessment

maps to

BambooHR

Employee Document or Custom Field

lossy
Fully supported

Assessment scores in Smart Hire's internal scale format require normalization before loading into BambooHR because BambooHR has no native psychometric module. We map raw scores, percentile ranks, and competency scores to typed custom fields on the Employee record (number fields for scores, text fields for competency labels). We validate score ranges during pre-migration profiling to catch improperly formatted assessment data.

Smart Hire

Custom Property (Candidate)

maps to

BambooHR

Custom Field (Employee)

1:1
Fully supported

Smart Hire custom properties on candidate records map to BambooHR custom fields on the Employee object. We detect the source field type during profiling (date, number, text, checkbox) and create a matching typed custom field in BambooHR before migration. If a custom property references a deleted or archived Smart Hire option value, we flag it for manual review. Custom fields must be provisioned in BambooHR admin before the production migration phase begins.

Smart Hire

Custom Property (Job Opening)

maps to

BambooHR

Custom Field (Job)

1:1
Fully supported

Smart Hire custom properties on job openings map to BambooHR custom fields on the Job object. These follow the same provisioning workflow as employee custom fields: type detection during profiling, schema creation in BambooHR admin, then data migration in the production phase. Job-level custom fields typically include hiring manager, department head, requisition approval status, or internal job code.

Smart Hire

Attachment (Resume)

maps to

BambooHR

Employee File

1:1
Fully supported

Resumes and supporting documents linked to Smart Hire candidate records migrate as files attached to the corresponding BambooHR Employee record. We export binary assets via the authenticated session, rename files to follow a consistent convention (CandidateName_DocumentType_date), and upload via BambooHR's file attachment API or direct file reference.

Smart Hire

User

maps to

BambooHR

User

1:1
Fully supported

Smart Hire user accounts (hiring managers, recruiters, admins) map to BambooHR User records. We extract the user email, name, and role assignment and match by email against the BambooHR destination account's User table. Role terminology differs between platforms: Smart Hire role labels map to BambooHR role and permission set assignments during scoping.

Smart Hire

Pipeline Stage

maps to

BambooHR

Job Stage

lossy
Fully supported

Smart Hire pipeline stages (Applied, Screening, Interview, Offer, Hired) map to BambooHR job applicant stages. We extract the full stage configuration from Smart Hire including stage ordering and any conditional stage-routing rules, then configure the matching stage list in BambooHR Jobs. If the destination account uses a customized stage vocabulary, we remap names during the migration transform.

Gotchas + challenges

What specifically takes care here

Platform-specific issues from each side, plus the pair-specific challenges that don't show up on either platform's page on its own.

Smart Hire logo

Smart Hire gotchas

High

Export mechanism is CSV-based, not REST API

Medium

Assessment score normalization requires field mapping

Medium

Custom fields may be untyped in CSV exports

Medium

Candidate-to-job associations can split during multi-file exports

BambooHR logo

BambooHR gotchas

High

Undocumented API rate limits can trigger 503 errors

High

Per-employee pricing model requires active record count verification

Medium

API credentials must be sent on every request to avoid extra round trips

Medium

Custom field schema varies per account and requires manual inventory

Low

Document and attachment exports are not covered by standard report exports

Pair-specific challenges

  • Smart Hire CSV export requires authenticated-session automation

    Smart Hire does not expose a documented public REST API for bulk data export. The primary export path is CSV downloads from the admin dashboard, which requires us to automate the download flow via authenticated browser sessions and parse the resulting CSV files. If candidate records span multiple dashboard pages or use custom export filters, we must iterate through each view to ensure complete data capture. This extends profiling time compared to API-first platforms and introduces a risk of incomplete export if the customer has applied filters not visible during automation. We validate row counts and field completeness after each export run and flag any discrepancy before proceeding to the transform phase.

  • BambooHR ATS module must be enabled before job application migration

    BambooHR's applicant tracking features (Jobs, Applicants, applicant status tracking) require the ATS module enabled on Pro or Elite plans ($17 or $25 per employee/month). If the destination account has the Core plan only ($10/employee/month), BambooHR's Jobs and Applicant objects are not available. In this case, we migrate candidate records as Employee records and store job associations in custom fields rather than native Job and Applicant records. This affects the migration schema design and must be confirmed before production migration begins.

  • Assessment score normalization requires pre-migration field mapping

    Psychometric scores stored in Smart Hire's internal scale format have no direct equivalent in BambooHR because BambooHR lacks a native psychometric module. We must map raw scores, percentile ranks, and competency scores to typed custom number or text fields on the BambooHR Employee record. We validate score ranges during pre-migration profiling to catch truncated or improperly formatted assessment data. If Smart Hire uses a non-numeric scale (letter grades, descriptive bands), we convert to a numeric scale agreed upon with the customer during scoping.

  • Custom fields must be provisioned in BambooHR before migration

    BambooHR requires custom fields to be created in the admin panel before any data can be written to them via the API. Unlike platforms that allow field creation during import, BambooHR enforces schema-first provisioning. This means our migration schedule includes a custom field provisioning phase in the BambooHR admin panel before the production data migration. Any custom properties discovered during profiling that were not included in the initial schema design add scope to this phase.

  • Candidate-to-job associations can split across multi-file exports

    When Smart Hire exports candidate records and job opening records as separate CSV files, the association between them relies on foreign key IDs embedded in the records. If the export does not include a consistent ID mapping across files, we must reconstruct the associations by matching candidate IDs to application records. We run a reconciliation step after export parsing to confirm every candidate is linked to at least one job opening before closing the migration. Orphaned candidates (candidates with no job association) are flagged for the customer's review.

Migration approach

Six steps for a successful Smart Hire to BambooHR data migration

  1. Discovery and export profiling

    We audit the Smart Hire admin portal to enumerate all record types in scope: candidate records, job openings, screening sessions, psychometric assessment exports, custom property schemas, and user accounts. We run trial CSV exports across each view (candidates, jobs, applications, users) to understand file structure, field headers, ID references across files, and any pagination or filter artifacts in the output. The discovery output is a written migration scope document with a complete field mapping draft, a list of custom fields to provision in BambooHR, and a confirmation of the BambooHR plan tier and ATS module status.

  2. BambooHR schema provisioning

    We create all required custom fields in the BambooHR admin panel before any data migration. This includes employee custom fields for assessment scores, screening session notes, and any candidate-level custom properties; job custom fields for requisition metadata; and any custom tabs or tables needed to replicate Smart Hire's data structure. We also confirm ATS module status on the destination account and configure job stage lists matching Smart Hire's pipeline vocabulary. Schema provisioning is validated by attempting a test employee creation via the BambooHR API with all custom fields populated before the production migration begins.

  3. CSV parsing, type coercion, and transform

    We parse all Smart Hire CSV exports using the field headers discovered during profiling. Type mismatches (dates stored as text, numbers stored as strings, empty strings where null is expected) are corrected during this phase. Assessment scores are normalized to the numeric or text format agreed upon during scoping. Candidate-to-job associations are reconstructed by matching foreign key IDs across the candidate export and the application/job export. Custom properties are mapped to their corresponding destination custom field IDs. The transform output is a set of typed, validated CSV files ready for BambooHR API ingestion.

  4. Sandbox validation (optional)

    If the customer requests validation before production migration, we run a sandbox migration using a cloned dataset representative of the full volume. The customer's HR lead spot-checks 25-50 candidate records against the Smart Hire source, verifies job association integrity, confirms assessment score accuracy, and signs off the sandbox results. Any mapping corrections are applied to the transform pipeline before the production migration phase begins. Sandbox validation adds approximately one week to the timeline.

  5. Production migration in dependency order

    We run production migration in record-dependency order: BambooHR Users (validated against the destination User table by email match), Employees (candidate data loaded with custom fields), Jobs (job openings loaded with custom fields), Employee Files (resume and document attachments linked to the corresponding employee), then screening session and assessment data (written to custom fields or notes on the employee record). Each phase emits a row-count reconciliation report showing records attempted, records succeeded, and any errors requiring remediation. BambooHR API rate limits are handled with exponential backoff and batch chunking throughout.

  6. Cutover, validation, and inventory handoff

    We freeze Smart Hire writes during cutover and run a final delta migration of any records modified during the migration window. We perform a final reconciliation comparing Smart Hire record counts to BambooHR record counts for each object type. We deliver the migration inventory document listing all active workflows, email templates, career site configurations, and any automation logic in Smart Hire that requires rebuild in BambooHR. We support a one-week post-migration hypercare window for reconciliation issues. We do not rebuild Smart Hire workflows, email templates, or career sites inside the migration scope; these are documented for the customer's admin to rebuild as a separate task.

Platform deep dives

Context on both ends of the pair

Smart Hire logo

Smart Hire

Source

Strengths

  • AI-assisted CV screening reduces manual resume review for high-volume roles
  • Psychometric and skills assessments are natively integrated into the screening workflow
  • Talent pipeline management supports building candidate pools for future openings
  • Custom career sites can be embedded or white-labeled for employer branding
  • Free job posting tier available with basic platform access

Weaknesses

  • API documentation is not publicly indexed, limiting programmatic migration access
  • Limited public pricing information makes cost-of-migration estimation harder
  • Smaller market presence means fewer third-party integration connectors
  • Export capabilities are primarily CSV-based rather than structured API endpoints
  • Support responsiveness and documentation depth lag behind enterprise ATS platforms
BambooHR logo

BambooHR

Destination

Strengths

  • Single platform consolidating ATS, onboarding, HR records, payroll, and time-off reduces system sprawl for SMBs.
  • Fast implementation — BambooHR reports four to six weeks from kickoff to go-live for most customers.
  • Per-employee pricing with automatic volume discounts makes cost predictable as headcount grows.
  • Strong customer support reputation (Support Heroes) cited consistently across G2, Capterra, and direct testimonials.
  • Well-documented API with UTF-8 encoding, clear field types, and HTTPS-only access.

Weaknesses

  • Mobile application is significantly limited compared to the desktop experience, frustrating remote and field workers.
  • Companies above 150–200 employees frequently outgrow the platform's feature depth and customization surface.
  • Limited advanced reporting and analytics compared to enterprise HR platforms — custom report building is the ceiling.
  • PTO and profile customization are pain points — non-standard accrual policies and complex org structures require workarounds.
  • Document management and attachment handling lack the granularity of dedicated document-centric HR systems.

Complexity grading

How hard is this migration?

Standard HRMS migration. All 7 core objects map 1:1 between Smart Hire and BambooHR.

B

Overall complexity

Standard migration

Derived from compatibility, mapping clarity, API constraints, and data volume across Smart Hire and BambooHR.

  • Object compatibility

    A

    All 7 core objects map 1:1 between Smart Hire and BambooHR.

  • Field mapping clarity

    C

    Field mapping is derived from defaults — final spec confirmed during the sample migration.

  • Timeline complexity

    B

    7-object category — typical timelines run 2–7 days end-to-end.

  • API constraints

    B

    Smart Hire: Not publicly documented.

  • Data volume sensitivity

    B

    Smart Hire doesn't expose a bulk API — REST + parallelization used for high-volume runs.

Estimator

Estimate your Smart Hire to BambooHR migration cost

Rule-based pricing — no per-record fees, no manual quotes. Migrations over 2M records are scoped individually.

Step 1

What are you migrating?

Pick a category, then your source and destination platforms.

Category

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about Smart Hire to BambooHR data migrations

Answers to the questions buyers ask most during Smart Hire to BambooHR migration scoping. Not seeing yours? Book a call.

Can't find your answer?

Walk through your Smart Hire to BambooHR migration with a real engineer — 30 minutes, free, written quote within 24 hours.

Book a free 30 minute consultation

Most migrations land between three and five weeks for accounts under 5,000 candidate records and 500 job openings with a straightforward custom field schema. Migrations with large psychometric assessment histories (thousands of scored assessments), extensive custom property sets (50+ custom fields), multi-file cross-reference reconciliation, or sandbox pre-validation move to six to ten weeks because of profiling iterations, custom field provisioning in BambooHR admin, and assessment score normalization. BambooHR custom field provisioning requires the customer's admin to create fields in the admin panel, which adds a required step to the timeline that cannot be fully automated.

Adjacent paths

Related migrations to explore

Ready when you are

Move from Smart Hire.
Land in BambooHR, intact.

Tell us record counts and timeline. We'll come back with a written quote inside 1 business day — no commitment, no sales pitch.

Accuracy guarantee Rollback included Quote in 1 business day