HRMS migration

Migrate from BeyondPay to Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Field-level mapping, validation, and rollback between BeyondPay and Bullhorn ATS & CRM. We move data and schema; workflows are rebuilt natively in Bullhorn ATS & CRM.

BeyondPay logo

BeyondPay

Source

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Destination

Bullhorn ATS & CRM logo

Compatibility

58%

7 of 12

objects map 1:1 between BeyondPay and Bullhorn ATS & CRM.

Complexity

BStandard

Timeline

3-5 weeks

Rollback included Accuracy guarantee Field-level validation

Overview

What this migration involves

BeyondPay and Bullhorn serve different operational layers — BeyondPay is a regional payroll and HCM service bureau built for Mid-Atlantic small businesses, while Bullhorn is a cloud ATS and CRM purpose-built for staffing and recruitment agencies. The migration is therefore not a like-for-like system swap but a multi-layer move: contractor and employee biographical data flows into Bullhorn Candidate and ClientContact records, historical payroll data (YTD wages, pay period earnings, tax withholdings) loads into Bullhorn custom objects or placement records for back-office use, and garnishments and benefit elections migrate as active deduction snapshots. The core challenge is that BeyondPay has no publicly documented API — all data extraction requires early coordination with BeyondPay's implementation team and CBIZ account management — while Bullhorn exposes a full REST API with custom object support for non-standard fields. We sequence the export around pay-period boundaries, chunk payroll histories by calendar year, and resolve Bullhorn entity lookups (Candidate, ClientContact, ClientCorporation, Placement) before loading so that no record is orphaned.

Field-level fidelity

Every standard and custom field arrives verified.

Schema-aware mapping

AI proposes the map; you confirm before any record moves.

Relationships preserved

Parent–child, lookups, and ownership stay linked.

Full activity history

Calls, emails, meetings — with original timestamps.

Attachments & notes

Documents, uploads, and inline notes move with the record.

Why teams make this switch

Two sides of the same decision

Leaving

BeyondPay logo

BeyondPay

What's pushing teams away

  • Limited self-service capabilities compared to modern cloud HCM platforms, driving churn as growing businesses require more employee and manager self-service features.
  • Regional focus on Mid-Atlantic states restricts usability for businesses expanding geographically or moving to states outside NJ and PA service areas.
  • Acquisition by CBIZ in 2020 created uncertainty about product roadmap, support continuity, and pricing direction for existing clients.
  • Lack of publicly documented API makes integration with modern HRIS, benefits administration, and time-tracking tools difficult, causing friction as businesses adopt broader HCM ecosystems.
  • Modern HCM competitors offer broader suites including recruiting, onboarding, performance management, and employee experience tools that BeyondPay does not provide.

Choosing

Bullhorn ATS & CRM logo

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

What's pulling them in

  • Agencies choose Bullhorn because it combines ATS and CRM in one platform, eliminating the need to switch between separate tools for candidate management and client relationship tracking.
  • The resume parser extracts contact details, work history, and skills into structured, searchable candidate profiles automatically without manual data entry, reportedly driving 24% more placements per recruiter.
  • Bullhorn's placement and split-billing model natively supports contract staffing workflows, handling start/end dates, overtime rules, and multi-party pay/charge rates in a single record.
  • The platform offers extensive third-party integrations through its Recruitment Cloud Marketplace, connecting with back-office, onboarding, and payroll systems used by staffing agencies.
  • 72% of Bullhorn customers are teams with fewer than 10 users, and Bullhorn's implementation team handles setup and data migration for small agencies going live within weeks.

Object mapping

How BeyondPay objects map to Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Each row shows how a BeyondPay object lands in Bullhorn ATS & CRM, including any object-level transformations, lookup resolution, or schema-design dependencies.

Typical mapping — final map is confirmed during the sample migration step.

BeyondPay

Employee

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Candidate and ClientContact

1:many
Fully supported

BeyondPay employee records (biographical data, hire date, job title, department, employment status) map to Bullhorn Candidate for active job seekers and to ClientContact for placed or employed candidates. We split by employment status: W-2 employees with active assignments in BeyondPay become Bullhorn ClientContacts attached to their corresponding ClientCorporation (the staffing firm's client); contract workers on assignment become Bullhorn Candidates with a Placement record linked to the ClientCorporation. Original BeyondPay hire date, department, and job title migrate as custom fields on both entities for compliance and audit purposes.

BeyondPay

Payroll History (YTD Wages)

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Custom Object (PayrollHistory) or Placement fields

lossy
Fully supported

Year-to-date wage totals, pay period earnings, deductions, and tax withholdings from BeyondPay migrate into Bullhorn custom objects (Front Office Growth or Enterprise tier) or as fields on the Placement record for back-office invoicing use. We chunk payroll exports by calendar year, load prior-year W-2 data before activating any new payroll run in Bullhorn Back Office, and flag any multi-state wage allocations for manual verification. Bullhorn ATS tier does not include custom objects; in that case, we store YTD wage snapshots as note attachments on the ClientContact or Placement record.

BeyondPay

Tax Configurations

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Tax Setup fields and Custom Object

lossy
Mapping required

Federal, state, and local tax codes, rates, and filing statuses configured in BeyondPay (particularly NJ and PA specific codes) must be translated to Bullhorn's tax table format if Bullhorn Back Office is active, or documented in a configuration guide for the customer's payroll admin to re-enter. We extract the tax jurisdiction list from BeyondPay during scoping, compare it against Bullhorn Back Office's supported state list, and flag any BeyondPay states not supported by Bullhorn for manual tax configuration post-migration.

BeyondPay

Direct Deposit Information

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Bullhorn Back Office (payroll module)

1:1
Mapping required

Bank account routing numbers and account numbers for employee direct deposit migrate as encrypted fields if Bullhorn Back Office is active, or are documented in a secure handoff file for the customer's payroll admin to re-enter in Bullhorn's payroll setup. We flag any BeyondPay employees with multiple split deposits for manual verification before loading, as bank account data requires accuracy above all else and split deposit configurations vary by payroll system. Bullhorn's Back Office direct deposit setup requires separate payroll configuration not covered by Bullhorn ATS alone.

BeyondPay

Benefit Elections

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Custom Object (BenefitElections) on ClientContact

1:1
Mapping required

Health, dental, vision, and retirement benefit elections and coverage levels migrate as current-state snapshots in a Bullhorn custom object attached to ClientContact. Historical benefit election changes and effective-dated transitions are noted but not migrated as full audit trails since most ATS platforms do not track benefit history with the same granularity as payroll systems. We flag any BeyondPay benefit carriers not recognized in Bullhorn Back Office for manual re-enrollment.

BeyondPay

Time Tracking Data

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Bullhorn Time & Expense (formerly MyPeopleNet)

1:1
Mapping required

Hourly employee time entries, overtime calculations, and accrual balances migrate as transaction records if the customer is activating Bullhorn Time & Expense as part of the migration. We flag whether BeyondPay tracks PTO and leave accruals separately, as Bullhorn Time & Expense has specific accrual tracking modules that must be configured before historical leave balance data is loaded. Time entry exports from BeyondPay are sequenced by pay period to align with Bullhorn's time tracking periods.

BeyondPay

Garnishments and Deductions

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Custom Object (Garnishments) on ClientContact

1:1
Mapping required

Court-ordered garnishments, voluntary deductions, and HSA or FSA contributions migrate as active deduction records in a Bullhorn custom object attached to ClientContact. We flag inactive garnishments separately with an end date and do not load them as active records. Bullhorn's Back Office supports deduction configurations but garnishment types, limits, and disposable income calculations must be verified against Bullhorn Back Office's supported garnishment table. Any garnishment type not supported in Bullhorn Back Office is flagged for manual re-entry by the customer's payroll admin.

BeyondPay

Workers Compensation Settings

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

WorkersCompLocation fields and Custom Object

lossy
Mapping required

WC class codes, rates, and carrier information are mapped to Bullhorn's WorkersCompLocation entity or a custom object on Placement. We verify that BeyondPay's class code tables align with the NCCI codes used in Bullhorn Back Office, as mismatches between class codes can cause audit failures in state WC filings. Carrier information migrates to the WorkersCompLocation carrier field. Any custom BeyondPay class codes not found in the standard NCCI table are flagged for manual classification review.

BeyondPay

Custom Fields

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Bullhorn Custom Fields or Custom Objects

lossy
Mapping required

BeyondPay configures custom fields per client with no public schema documentation. We request a complete field inventory from the BeyondPay implementation team during discovery, map each BeyondPay custom field to either a Bullhorn native field (if a matching standard field exists), a Bullhorn Custom Field (if the Bullhorn edition supports custom fields on the entity), or a Bullhorn Custom Object (if no suitable field exists on the entity). Bullhorn ATS Growth does not support custom fields on standard entities; Enterprise or Front Office Growth is required for custom field migration. Any fields without a clear Bullhorn equivalent are flagged for manual review and either mapped to a custom destination field or excluded from the initial migration scope.

BeyondPay

Reports and Report Templates

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Not migrated

1:1
Not supported

BeyondPay custom report definitions, scheduled reports, and saved report configurations are not migratable because BeyondPay does not expose a documented report export or template API. We deliver a written inventory of all active BeyondPay reports with their field selections, filters, and scheduling parameters during scoping, so the customer's admin can rebuild them in Bullhorn's reporting module post-migration. Bullhorn's report builder supports candidate pipeline reports, placement activity, and back-office invoicing reports but may not replicate every BeyondPay payroll-specific report format.

BeyondPay

Company Records (if present)

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

ClientCorporation

1:1
Fully supported

If BeyondPay stores any employer or client company information (separate from the staffing firm's own employee records), those map to Bullhorn ClientCorporation. The BeyondPay company address, industry classification, and account manager fields map to ClientCorporation address, businessSector, and ownerId respectively. If BeyondPay does not store separate company records (beyond the employer's own record), we skip this object and rely on Bullhorn's ClientCorporation setup for the staffing firm's clients separately.

BeyondPay

User and Owner Records

maps to

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Bullhorn User

1:1
Fully supported

BeyondPay does not expose a user or owner concept equivalent to Bullhorn's User record. However, if BeyondPay tracks payroll administrators or HR contacts, we map those to Bullhorn User records by email match. Any BeyondPay contact without a matching Bullhorn User goes to a reconciliation queue for the customer's Bullhorn admin to provision. Bullhorn requires active User records for all staff who will log in; recruiters without Bullhorn User accounts are not migrated as Users.

Gotchas + challenges

What specifically takes care here

Platform-specific issues from each side, plus the pair-specific challenges that don't show up on either platform's page on its own.

BeyondPay logo

BeyondPay gotchas

High

No publicly documented API for automated data export

Medium

Acquisition by CBIZ may affect account standing and export cooperation

Medium

Custom fields and client-specific configurations lack public schema

Medium

Historical payroll data retention and year boundaries require deliberate sequencing

Bullhorn ATS & CRM logo

Bullhorn ATS & CRM gotchas

High

ATS Growth edition has no API access

High

Attachments excluded from CSV bulk exports

Medium

Custom Object limits vary sharply by edition

Medium

Opportunity pipeline stages are recruitment-specific

Low

Resume parse quality varies by document format

Pair-specific challenges

  • BeyondPay has no public API — export requires implementation team coordination

    BeyondPay does not publish a developer API or public data export documentation. All data extraction requires coordination with the BeyondPay implementation team or CBIZ account management, who produce exports manually or via internal tools. We engage BeyondPay early in scoping to establish export timelines, confirm data completeness, and agree on file formats (CSV, Excel) before we begin transformation and loading work in Bullhorn. Delays in BeyondPay's export response directly extend the migration timeline. We recommend initiating the export request in the discovery phase rather than waiting for contract signature.

  • Bullhorn ATS does not support custom objects — edition determines migration scope

    Bullhorn's custom object support varies by edition: Front Office Growth and Enterprise support up to 10 searchable Custom Objects with 55 fields each; ATS Growth has none; Bullhorn ATS supports 2. BeyondPay data that has no native Bullhorn equivalent (benefit elections, garnishments, historical payroll snapshots, custom BeyondPay fields) requires Custom Objects on Bullhorn. If the customer is on ATS Growth, we store non-standard data as note attachments with structured body content or as CSV exports in Bullhorn's document management, not as searchable records. We confirm the Bullhorn edition before designing the schema and advise on upgrading if the migration scope requires Custom Objects not available on the selected tier.

  • Bullhorn is an ATS/CRM, not a payroll processor — full payroll data may not fit

    BeyondPay is a full payroll service bureau with complete payroll processing, tax filing, and compliance capabilities. Bullhorn ATS and CRM (Starter, Core, Pro) do not include payroll processing by default; Bullhorn Back Office is a separate optional module. Historical payroll data (YTD wages, pay period earnings, tax withholdings) that fits naturally in BeyondPay has no native home in Bullhorn ATS. We map payroll histories to Bullhorn Custom Objects (if available) or Placement record fields, but Bullhorn Back Office must be activated and configured for the data to be actionable. We clarify during scoping whether Bullhorn Back Office is in scope, and if not, we store payroll data as documentation records rather than live payroll data.

  • Payroll history must be sequenced around pay-period and calendar-year boundaries

    Migrating current-year and prior-year payroll histories from BeyondPay must be sequenced correctly to preserve W-2 accuracy and avoid duplicate wage records. We chunk payroll exports by calendar year, load prior-year data before activating the current-year payroll run in Bullhorn Back Office, and flag any mid-year hires whose BeyondPay records span calendar boundaries. Running a payroll in Bullhorn Back Office before loading historical wage data can create duplicate wage records that require correction before year-end W-2 filing. We coordinate the payroll cutover date with the customer's payroll administrator to minimize the gap between final BeyondPay payroll and first Bullhorn payroll.

  • CBIZ acquisition may affect export authorization and support escalation

    Since December 2020, BeyondPay operates as a CBIZ subsidiary. Account management, support escalation paths, and export request processes may now route through CBIZ rather than directly through BeyondPay staff. We verify current account contacts and confirm export authorization with CBIZ before initiating migration work. If the customer's BeyondPay account is managed under a CBIZ master agreement, export requests may require additional approvals. We include a CBIZ contact verification step in our discovery checklist before committing to migration timelines.

Migration approach

Six steps for a successful BeyondPay to Bullhorn ATS & CRM data migration

  1. Discovery and export initiation

    We audit the BeyondPay account across current employee count, payroll history depth (prior year and current year), active garnishments and deductions, benefit election records, workers comp class codes, and any custom fields configured per client. We also confirm the Bullhorn edition and modules in scope (ATS only, ATS plus Back Office, or ATS plus Back Office plus Time & Expense). Simultaneously, we initiate the export request with BeyondPay's implementation team or CBIZ account management, providing a structured data request list and agreeing on file formats and delivery timelines. The export request is the critical path item for this migration.

  2. Schema design in Bullhorn

    We design the destination schema in Bullhorn based on the export data received. This includes configuring Custom Objects (if the Bullhorn edition supports them) for PayrollHistory, BenefitElections, Garnishments, and any BeyondPay custom fields; setting up WorkersCompLocation records for each WC class code; mapping BeyondPay employee fields to Bullhorn Candidate and ClientContact fields; and configuring Bullhorn Back Office tax tables for applicable states (NJ, PA, and any additional states in the payroll history). Schema is validated in a Bullhorn sandbox or test company before production migration begins.

  3. Payroll history sequencing and year-boundary extraction

    We extract payroll data from BeyondPay in two chunks: prior-year data (for W-2 history and audit trail) and current-year data (from January 1 of the current year through the most recent completed pay period). We verify that mid-year hires have continuous records spanning the calendar boundary. Prior-year data is loaded first into Bullhorn Custom Objects or Placement records before any current-year payroll is initiated in Bullhorn Back Office. We produce a reconciliation report showing total gross wages, total taxes withheld, and total net pay per employee to compare against the BeyondPay W-2 forms.

  4. Candidate and ClientContact migration

    We run the production migration of BeyondPay employee records into Bullhorn Candidate and ClientContact objects in dependency order. First, any ClientCorporation records for the staffing firm's clients are created or matched. Then, current active employees (W-2 staff) are loaded as ClientContact records linked to the staffing firm's own ClientCorporation. Then, contract workers and candidates are loaded as Bullhorn Candidate records. Each record is tagged with a custom field identifying it as migrated from BeyondPay and carrying the original BeyondPay employee ID for audit traceability.

  5. Garnishment and deduction load

    Active garnishments, voluntary deductions, HSA contributions, and FSA elections are loaded into Bullhorn Custom Objects (Garnishments, BenefitElections) attached to the corresponding ClientContact record. We validate each garnishment record against court order documentation (if available), check that deduction amounts and percentages align with Bullhorn Back Office's supported deduction types, and flag any garnishments with missing or invalid case numbers. Inactive garnishments are loaded with an end date and not marked as active deductions. The customer's Bullhorn Back Office admin reviews and approves all loaded deductions before the first Bullhorn payroll run.

  6. Cutover, validation, and payroll go-live handoff

    We freeze BeyondPay write access during cutover, run a final delta migration of any records modified during the migration window, and deliver a reconciliation summary comparing BeyondPay record counts to Bullhorn record counts by entity type. We deliver the Bullhorn Back Office configuration guide (tax tables, deduction types, WC codes, direct deposit setup) to the customer's payroll admin for manual completion. We support a one-week hypercare window for record reconciliation issues. We do not configure Bullhorn Back Office payroll processing, tax filing, or direct deposit setup as those require Bullhorn's payroll module configuration and the customer's payroll admin's direct engagement with Bullhorn Back Office.

Platform deep dives

Context on both ends of the pair

BeyondPay logo

BeyondPay

Source

Strengths

  • Founded by CPAs with deep in-house tax and compliance expertise available to all clients.
  • Hands-on implementation and account management for small businesses without dedicated HR tech staff.
  • Acquired by CBIZ, providing access to broader financial, insurance, and advisory services.
  • Bundled services including direct deposit, check printing, and tax filing without add-on pricing.
  • Regional service model with dedicated support representatives familiar with NJ and PA payroll regulations.

Weaknesses

  • No publicly documented API limits data export to manual or implementation-assisted processes.
  • Regional focus on Mid-Atlantic limits functionality for businesses with multi-state or national workforces.
  • Acquired by CBIZ in 2020; product roadmap and pricing direction under new ownership are unclear.
  • Self-service capabilities lag behind modern cloud HCM platforms, particularly for employee and manager portals.
  • Does not offer recruiting, onboarding, performance management, or broader talent management modules.
Bullhorn ATS & CRM logo

Bullhorn ATS & CRM

Destination

Strengths

  • Unified ATS and CRM on one platform purpose-built for staffing agencies, eliminating separate tools for candidates and clients.
  • Automated resume parsing extracts structured candidate data—contact details, work history, skills—into searchable profiles instantly.
  • Native placement and split-billing model handles contract staffing workflows including start/end dates and overtime rules.
  • Bullhorn Recruitment Cloud Marketplace offers 100+ pre-validated third-party integrations spanning the full recruiting lifecycle.
  • 24/7 global support coverage from 350+ support staff with dedicated account management included at all tiers.

Weaknesses

  • Widely regarded as old and bloated with an unintuitive interface and steep learning curve for new recruiters.
  • Slow page loads and performance lag cited in over 200 verified G2 reviews during high-volume recruiting periods.
  • Pricing is opaque—custom-negotiated per organization with significant upfront implementation fees that vary by deal.
  • ATS Growth edition excludes API access entirely, preventing automated data export without upgrading first.

Complexity grading

How hard is this migration?

Standard HRMS migration. 2 of 7 objects need a mapping; the rest are 1:1.

B

Overall complexity

Standard migration

Derived from compatibility, mapping clarity, API constraints, and data volume across BeyondPay and Bullhorn ATS & CRM.

  • Object compatibility

    B

    2 of 7 objects need a mapping; the rest are 1:1.

  • Field mapping clarity

    C

    Field mapping is derived from defaults — final spec confirmed during the sample migration.

  • Timeline complexity

    B

    7-object category — typical timelines run 2–7 days end-to-end.

  • API constraints

    B

    BeyondPay: Not publicly documented.

  • Data volume sensitivity

    B

    BeyondPay doesn't expose a bulk API — REST + parallelization used for high-volume runs.

Estimator

Estimate your BeyondPay to Bullhorn ATS & CRM migration cost

Rule-based pricing — no per-record fees, no manual quotes. Migrations over 2M records are scoped individually.

Step 1

What are you migrating?

Pick a category, then your source and destination platforms.

Category

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about BeyondPay to Bullhorn ATS & CRM data migrations

Answers to the questions buyers ask most during BeyondPay to Bullhorn ATS & CRM migration scoping. Not seeing yours? Book a call.

Can't find your answer?

Walk through your BeyondPay to Bullhorn ATS & CRM migration with a real engineer — 30 minutes, free, written quote within 24 hours.

Book a free 30 minute consultation

Most migrations land between three and five weeks for accounts under 500 employees with single-state (NJ or PA) payroll, active garnishments under 50, and Bullhorn ATS (no Back Office) in scope. Migrations with multi-state payroll histories spanning NJ, PA, and additional states, active Bullhorn Back Office configuration, historical benefit elections, or prior-year W-2 data requiring calendar-year sequencing move to eight to fourteen weeks because of export coordination delays, payroll history chunking, and Bullhorn Back Office tax table setup. The export coordination with BeyondPay and CBIZ is the critical path item that most affects timeline.

Adjacent paths

Related migrations to explore

Ready when you are

Move from BeyondPay.
Land in Bullhorn ATS & CRM, intact.

Tell us record counts and timeline. We'll come back with a written quote inside 1 business day — no commitment, no sales pitch.

Accuracy guarantee Rollback included Quote in 1 business day